This post is also available in:
English
Short answer
Funny how people throw the word “apartheid” at Israel, but never mention this — Israelis (especially Jews) are banned from entering Area A, which is fully controlled by the Palestinian Authority. That’s right, Jews literally can’t step foot there. Meanwhile, Palestinians enter Israel daily for work, medical care, and more. If you’re looking for real segregation, this is it — apartheid against Israelis, plain and simple.
Long answer
The term “apartheid” is often thrown at Israel without context, but few are willing to acknowledge one glaring reality: Israeli citizens — particularly Jews — are banned from entering Area A of the West Bank, which is under full control of the Palestinian Authority.
Let’s clarify what that means. Area A, established under the Oslo Accords, is administered entirely by the PA, both in terms of civil governance and security. Israeli law explicitly prohibits its citizens from entering these zones — not because of a political disagreement, but because of serious safety concerns. This policy is enforced by Israel to protect its people from the very real risk of violence, abduction, or even lynching should they mistakenly enter.
This is not hypothetical. There have been numerous incidents where Israeli civilians, including those who accidentally crossed into Area A, faced immediate threats to their lives. In response, Israel has established legal restrictions barring entry to these areas — effectively acknowledging that these regions are not safe for its own citizens.
Now contrast this with the freedom of movement granted to Palestinians. Tens of thousands of Palestinians from the West Bank enter Israel daily for work, medical treatment, and other needs — often through coordinated permits that allow access to Israeli hospitals, job sites, and services. Despite ongoing security risks, Israel continues to facilitate this movement, understanding that most Palestinians are not involved in terrorism and that human dignity must be preserved.
So where’s the so-called “apartheid”? If anything, the one-sided reality is that Israelis — especially Jews — are restricted from entering entire areas due to threats against their lives, while Palestinians move freely into Israeli territory with the protection of Israeli law. This stark asymmetry is rarely discussed in mainstream narratives.
If the definition of apartheid is “segregation based on ethnicity or nationality,” then surely the enforced exclusion of Jews from Palestinian-controlled areas — coupled with the Palestinian population’s regular access to Israeli society — raises important questions about who is segregating whom.
It’s time to move past simplistic slogans and take a serious, balanced look at the facts. Accusations of apartheid lose their meaning when used selectively and without full context. In this case, the reality on the ground reveals a far more complex — and often inverted — dynamic.
